Urban Flood Risks, Water Law and Insurance

Written by peter@uwcs.com.au

October 20, 2023

Urban flood risks, water law and insurance: The intersection of emerging science, practice and authority

 By Professor Peter J Coombes

Published in Precedent issue 178 – September/October 2023, Journal of the Australian Lawyers Alliance

This article discusses the complex challenge of estimating flood risks in Australian urban areas and determining insurance contracts for recovery of storm and flood damages. Considerations include revised national guidelines for flood estimation (after 30 years); rapidly evolving science, methods and models; variable weather; a changing climate and a complex array of legislation and regulation. The application of emerging science is uncertain. Not even the definition of flood is settled in this context. We need to find a clear definition of flood risk that applies across multiple disciplines, and equitable processes for flood resilience.

We need a Pareto (balanced) analysis of costs and benefits to incorporate these trade-offs and achieve equity in finding the acceptable flood risk for particular locations. There is a need to prepare for rare flood events and to develop a reliable and defensible understanding of the potential impacts. However, there is also a requirement for normal activity between contested rare events that is more aligned with flood resilience approaches. We should not be sterilising high value land from human endeavour by an unduly conservative application of flood models, planning overlays and building assessments.

A copy of the journal paper is available here: Precedent 178 Peter J Coombes

About
Dr Peter Coombes

Dr Coombes has spent more than 30 years dedicated to the development of systems understanding of the urban, rural and natural water cycles with a view to finding optimum solutions for the sustainable use of ecosystem services, provision of infrastructure and urban planning.

Connect with Peter

Related Articles

Water Regulation, Legislation, Monopoly and Preference for Utility Infrastructure

Water Regulation, Legislation, Monopoly and Preference for Utility Infrastructure

New Journal paper from Peter J Coombes explores the influence of regulation, legislation and monopoly processes on preference for utility supply side infrastructure. The effects of price regulation and preference for utility supply infrastructure on Australian urban water utilities and urban water markets are considered by examination of historical data and models of the future of a case study of the Greater Sydney and Melbourne regions. Interesting read in the context of requests to double water bills and limit user pays pricing

Rainwater harvesting and systems thinking for a better world – release of YouTube Channel

Rainwater harvesting and systems thinking for a better world – release of YouTube Channel

The Essential Rainwater Harvesting Course was created by Peter Coombes of Urban Water Cycle Solutions (https://urbanwatercyclesolutions.com) and Michelle Avis of Verge Permaculture (https://vergepermaculture.ca). First recorded in 2020, a large majority of the course is now being released, for free, on YouTube as part of our shared mission to educate and spread information on rainwater harvesting as widely as possible.

Rethinking responses to the world’s water crises

Rethinking responses to the world’s water crises New journal paper published by Nature Sustainability by the ANU team lead by Quentin Grafton and our colleagues. The world faces multiple water crises, including overextraction, flooding, ecosystem degradation and...

SYSTEMS PERSPECTIVE ON CHARACTERISING RESILIENCE IN URBAN WATER MARKETS

SYSTEMS PERSPECTIVE ON CHARACTERISING RESILIENCE IN URBAN WATER MARKETS

Results from two decades of accumulated big data and systems analysis of Greater Melbourne and Sydney was investigated to develop insights into the resilience of each city. The key resilience parameters are distributed water sources and conservation in an urban water market, household welfare, government policy and regulation, pricing strategies, total dam storage and supply of desalinated water. These parameters have different levels of impact and significance across the two cities. Further studies are needed to better define the attributes and benefits of these parameters.

Systems Frameworks of Big Data: Averages, Economics and Policy

Systems Frameworks of Big Data: Averages, Economics and Policy

Systems Frameworks of Big Data: Averages, Economics and Policy Peter J Coombes at the GK Symposium 12 - 13 June 2019 at Noahs at Newcastle Beach Bottom up systems analysis highlights the illusion of averages and economic opportunities for development of government...

Making the Paper: Impact of Averages on Water Modelling

Making the Paper: Impact of Averages on Water Modelling

Making of the paper: Planning resilient water resources and communities: the need for a bottom up systems approach
Michael E Barry and Peter J Coombes. Impact of averages on water modelling.
This paper was awarded the GN Alexander Medal by the Engineers Australia National Committee on Water Engineering. This Medal is usually awarded every 18 months for the best paper in hydrology and/or water resources published in an Engineers Australia publication.
This article presents an overview of the processes leading to making this journal paper.

c